RE BLOG: Entering a Juried Quilt Show

Entering a Juried Quilt Show


Entering quilt shows has been a hot topic on the internet on several blogs, e-magazines and pod casts. I have been following the discussion because I had been considering entering the AQS QUILT SHOW in Grand Rapids this summer ( or 2013 or 2014.) What better opportunity then to enter one of the big shows in my home state. I have investigated what standards the quilts are judge upon and want to take the plunge. To that end here is the information I have discovered for my guild sisters who might also want to enter one of the larger quilt shows.

( Deadline for entry is April 30, 2012) Below I have posted links the AQS show in Grand Rapids. Be sure to register as soon as possible in order to get your entry instructions.)

Important information:
Be sure to observe all deadlines. Early entries are permissible and encouraged. Quilts submitted after the deadlines are dismissed out of hand, regardless of how beautiful your quilt is. Be sure to follow any instructions about submission for a particular category or group. Read the rules and regulations carefully and follow them.

Follow the rules for the type of photographs required. For the national quilt shows a professional photograph might be desirable. MOST quilt shows will not accept photographs that have been edited in any manner. Following the directions be prepared to submit a head on shot of yourself, a picture of the entire quilt, details of the quilting and close ups of the important details of the quilt. Most photographs are to be submitted in digital format ( CD) but some places still require slides. You must submit the photographs in the format they request.

The rules for the quilt show are set by the hosting organization and will change from show to show. The national shows usually have certified judges, judges who will judge the quilt based on predetermined standards. Judges can be trained and certified by the National Quilting Association, or they can be trained through experience. They all adhere to similar standards of judging, although final results will be varied based on the individuals. There are several method of tallying the points for judging the quilt and the hosting organization will determine what criteria is used. It is usually spelled out in the quilt entry form. Quilts are judged individually then against other quilts in their category and classifications. Best of show quilts are the most perfect quilts with the best workmanship and design elements in the show.

What is important to remember is that having your quilts judged is to improve your techniques for the next quilt, to learn from the judge’s comments. Do not take comments personally but use them as a springboard for improving your workmanship.

What criteria are used for JUDGING A QUILT?
Design / Technique/ Workmanship / Presentation

Presentation:
In her podcast Annie Smith stresses the importance of having your quilt “SHOW READY”. Many beautiful quilts have been knocked out of completion because of pet hair, lint, stains, and odors. Be sure all threads are buried and none are left dangling from construction. All marking should be removed. BE SURE YOUR QUILT IS IMPECCABLY CLEAN.

WORKMANSHIP:
Technique:
For the most part like quilts are judged against each other in their respective categories. It is important to read the rules carefully and enter your quilt in the correct category. What-ever technique you chose it should the best workmanship that you can achieve. Again no dangling threads, applique should be well stitched with invisible stitches. Pieced blocks should have points not cut off or into the seam allowance.

Pay attention to the basics of construction and do the absolute best that you can.

Over all look of the quilt and the impact it has on viewers is important.

Does it hang straight? Are the edges straight and plumb?

Does the quilt lie flat?

DO the borders wave?

Precision of seam allowance is examined.

Are points cut off are they lost into seam allowance?

Threads not buried but hanging off the quilt

Quilting details, regardless of what type of quilting (Hand, domestic or long-arm.) Is it consistent type of quilting being used. Are the stitches even, standard in size and shape? Was the quilting by an individual, a group or professional long arm quilter. (Credit must be given to whoever did the quilting.)

Hand quilting (stitches even size on front and back of quilt, starts and stops not visible, quilt marking lines not visible.)

Machine Quilting (domestic or long armed) is examined for correct tension, thread dots on back of quilt. They look for the starts and stops and the expertise of the back tracts. Thread nests are especially frowned upon.

Does the stitch in the ditch come out of the ditch? More and more shows are judging the quilting against the same type of quilts. (Hand against hand, domestic against domestic and long arm against long arm.) The judges realize different skill sets are required for the different types of quilting.

The binding is especially important. Are the thread hanging, missed stitches gaps in the stitching? Are there any parts where the binding is empty or weak? Are the corners sewn closed on top and bottom? Is the size of the binding uniform; is there any pulling to the back to cover the stitches attaching the binding? Stitches that attach the binding to the quilt should not be seen, but covered by the binding. No batting should be poking through.


DESIGN ELEMENT OF JUDGING:

• Visual impact of design – The quilt must be visible across the room! It needs to be eye-catching
• Originality and creativity
• Color and value
• Balance and integration of design (scale, relationship and arrangement of quilt components including borders)
• Overall appearance (quilt is clean, free of odor, and hangs squarely)
• General construction – workmanship (piecing, applique, borders even)
• Level of difficulty
• Special techniques (if applicable)
• Machine quilting (stitches of even length, no tension problems – Bobbin thread should not show on top and top thread should not show on back. Starts and stops not visible.)
• Quilting design appropriate to quilt top, density of quilting consistent
• Finishing (binding applied securely, evenly and accurately, square corners – no dog ears)

Art Quilts are judged on their merits …

There are more shows being established just for the art quilts. The impact of the design, the artistic expression, composition and all the rules of art are most important for these quilts. That said, technique is still considered to be important part of the judging of these quilts.

Embellishments adhered correctly and are secure

Subjects not taken into consideration and judges try not to allow their own biases and preferences sway them.

Creativity

Color

Harmonious design

Technical skills are judged


Sources:

http://aqsshows.com/AQSGrandRapids/.. REGISTRATION, CLASSES
http://aqsshows.com/AQSGrandRapids/contests …Contests and Deadlines

*****

Annie Smith, Quilting Stash blog and podcast
http://simplearts.com Podcast 209-210 and 211
*****

Quilt Judging

http://www.bukisa.com/articles/348120_criteria-used-in-judging-quilt-contests …. Criteria used in judging a quilt

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “RE BLOG: Entering a Juried Quilt Show

  1. BASICALLY this is a re-post of an older previous podcast but since this is QUILT SHOW SEASON this is a good re-post.

    I know the show will be in Grand Rapids this year but I do not for sure it will be the next year. Keep putting your quilts into shows. Just be aware when it comes to judges the quality of their ability to judge varies …. What is desirable is to be judged by certified judge that has gone through training, they are few and far between. They are also expensive . Many local or regional shows use local experienced quilters, local quilt celebrities, quilt shop owners, etc . . . many of them do not have credentials but they have studied and made quilts for eons. It all depends on what the QUILT SHOW HOSTS has arranged. I have always asked about the judges and their qualifications. That said, I have only entered local and regional quilt shows not the big one… HOUSTON, Paducah or any of the AQS shows. There are also other big shows to consider …
    .
    .
    I personally think what most shows are looking for as well as EXCELLENT WORKMANSHIP is ORIGINALITY. They want spectacular quilts. From the big shows I see on- line the winners all seem to be original designs made by the quilt maker … not patterns from other quilters. I have never made one of those quilts ( YOU have,) that is why I only enter the local / regional quilt shows. What I do know is every time I get the judges comments I learn how to improve my next quilt.
    .
    .
    As for winning quilts I think it is important to remember that the quilts you enter are judged against the other quilts at the show. At some shows there may be a more experience quilters who has entered a quilt that is judged higher. ( Most judges have a number scale they use to judge. I think from certification agency … see links below.) What you come away with hopefully is a better understanding of how to make better quilts. Try to learn from the judgement and not take it as condemnation or a negative.
    .
    .
    FYI: The ONLY ribbon I ever won was 3RD place in a viewers choice against 150 other quilts.

    GOOD LUCK DARLA … LET us know how things go… and know us TWILTERS are rooting for you.

    Nonnie

    .
    http://www.nqaquilts.org/certified-judge/
    .
    http://www.nqaquilts.org/certified-judge/list/
    .
    http://www.nqaquilts.org/certified-judge/whatexpect/
    .
    .

  2. It is funny you talk about this today. I am entering my quilt for judging in the Kansas City Regional show as you may have heard a million times. It is NOT juried, for which I am thankful.

    The quilter who quilted my quilt recently had her quilt in the juried show at Paducah. She showed me her comment card, which was actually laughable. It said under good points “great zig zag design”, and under areas work on “binding” and “quilting”. That’s it. Not very much learning could happen with that comment card, not really.

    Hmm. I wonder if I would consider getting my royal red quilt up to the Grand Rapids show too. Hmm…. Some of it depends on what happens with the KC show, but I was/am/maybe considering coming to Grand Rapids either this year or next. I was for sure going to try to come to GR this year, but then the regional show fell into our lap and hopefully we will get a few twilters down/up at KC for that event. If that falls through completely and everyone backs out, I will try to double-down GRapids this year, if not, maybe next year.

    I definitely have one flaw in my royal red quilt (more than one, but this is noticeable) due to that flaw, I am uncertain if I would want to put this quilt into a juried show. It may be fun to try. If not this year, maybe next.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s